http://online.wsj.com/public/article/SB121392004594090355.html?mod=sports
I stumble on to a pretty fun little Wall Street Journal article about how to figure out the greatest athlete in the world. Being the WSJ, they are very right-brained, thorough, and scientific about the process. The difference between what their editors said, and what you might say in a local drafthouse over this same subject matter? They based it on six categories, and then each person came up with their own top 10 list. Below are their results, as well as the criteria for their selection.
1. Roman Sebrle: First decathlete to reach 9000 points in a competition
2. LeBron James: We all know about him on a court, but he was also an All-State WR his junior year, at 6'8" 225 lbs!
3. Floyd Mayweather, boxing: 39-0 in what is probably the most physically demanding sport
4. Ladanian tomlinson, San Diego Chargers: I think he got points for his uncanny start-stop-restart abilities. Plus he's a badazz RB
5. Roger Federer, tennis dominator: Combines sprinter's speed with an acrobats reflexes/coordination
6. Sindey crosby, NHL Pittsburgh Penguins: arguably hockey's best athlete
7. Lui Xiang, 110m hurdler: dude RAN 19.5 mph while jumping over 3.5 foot hurdles to set the 110m world record!
8. Jeremy Wariner, 400m gold medal sprinter: 400m and 800m runners are crazy
9. Ronaldo de Assis Moreiera, FC barcelona: Don't know much about soccer, but I don't doubt his place on the list. Any soccer guys with input?
10. Alex Rodriguez, NY Yankees:ARoid is 6'3" 225 lbs, and is considered one of the top athletes in baseball.
The list was comprised using these criteria, and I'll list the top performer for each:
-Vision and Reflex: Lewis hamilton, Formula One racing
-Stamina and Recovery: Alberto Contidar, cycling
-Power, Strength, and size: Vladimir Klistchko, boxing
-Speed: Asafa Powell, Jamaican 100m WR holder (at the time)
-Success and Competitiveness of Sport: Tiger Woods
-Coordination and Flexibility: Yang Wei, gymnast
Although I don't doubt the validity of the list, I would like to make a few changes. You can keep pretty much everyone on the list except for Crosby, ARoid, and drop LdT a couple spots. I have to think that there is a better athlete in the NHL besides the waify Penguin; although I don't watch hockey, so I don't know of anyone. Maybe even the soccer guy, with the same reasoning. It is my own personal bias that an IronMan triathlete woud be on the list; however, they would be lascking in other areas of the criteria (speed, sucess, and power strength & size). I would also have to bring up crossover pro athletes into the mix. I know that there are TONS of NFL players that could probably make an NBA team, although they would probably ride the pine-but that's not the type of crossover type that I'm talking about. I'm thinking lesser-knowns, like Brock Lesnar, Sheila Taormina, and Eva Twardokens to name a few. Brock Lesnar is a former NFL defensive lineman, who had a stint in pro wrestling (not a sport, but still a demanding profession), before beoming a Mixed Martial Arts (MMA) stud. MMA is known for being intensely grueling, and those how do it claim it to be the toughest athletic endeavour around. Sheila T just recently qualified for the 2008 Beijing Olympic games in the Modern Pentathlon event (shooting, fencing, swimming, equestrian, and running). The remarkable thing about this is that she has also competed in two other Olympic events: a gold medal winner on the 1996 US 4x200m relay team, and triathlon competitor in 2000 (6th place) and 2004 (23rd). I think that's pretty remarkable. Eva T (no relation) is a 2x Olympic skier, who is one of the strongest people in the world, pound-for-pound. Another athlete that nearly mmissed the list was myself. Many people forget that I have experience in gymnastics, wrestling, running, triathlon, and football. Another lesser-known fact about yours truly is that I was twice named All-Blesser team in Avon Lake pickup basketball, one of my proudest achievements.
Anyways, it's a pretty cool take on a conversation sports fans have been having for years. Beats watching baseball....bring on the NBA draft!
Sheila T story:
http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2008/06/02/AR2008060200814.html
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
6 comments:
I have a few others for the list. This is a great conversation piece though. Here we go.
Michael Phelps-USA Swimming, 7 gold medals, 20 time world record holder
Lance Armstrong-7 time Tour de France winner, beat cancer, ran in NYC marathon in like 3:10
Tiger Woods-14 time PGA champion, #1 golfer in the world, walks miles and miles each week(except now because of his ACL surgery), and he can hit it a TON.
Also, the Asafa Powell world record for the 100M was broken about two weeks ago by another Jamacian Usain Bolt at 9.72! That is flying.
I can attest to your wrestling prowess, as I have a rather large box of CYO trophies in my attic in the gargage that have your name inscribed on them(would love to get rid of these by the way). I can also speak to your basketball skills, as I have seen those first hand on many an occasion. At any rate, I'm sure you should be rated somewhere on a list for something, but I'm not sure for what.
Jon: Did you read the WSJ article? They rule out Phelps and Tiger. Here: "iger Woods, a dominant figure in professional sports, didn't crack the Top 10. Panelists said they didn't give golfers much weight when assessing overall athletic ability. Michael Phelps, one of the greatest U.S. swimmers of all time, also missed the top tier because, the judges said, swimmers generally don't perform well out of the water. Such endurance athletes as marathoners and Tour de France cyclists also failed to impress. Too one-dimensional, the panel said."
A few guys I know work out at the same gym as Tiger down here, and they say he can throw down some weight. I have a feeling he'd be a monster at whatever sport he chooses to compete in.
Frank: So you have the testiment to my CYO dominance? I guess you can toss them, or keep them and put your name in for mine.
Lance wouldn't be a bad addition to the list, but I don't know how strong he is, above the waist. He was an up-and-coming amatuer triathlete prior to getting cancer.
I'm a little pretirbed why an Elite Pro ironMan racer wasn't listed. A guy that can swin 2.4 miles (in about 50 minutes), bike 112 (averaging 25 mph), and run a marathon (in around 3:15) is a pretty good mix of all the criteria.
Yes I read the article DAD...However I made my argument as to why they need to be there.
I did find out that LT is like a 10 handicap in golf...
Your blog is on slacker mode...
I guess we can tell the WSJ to take A-Roid off of this list now huh?
Post a Comment